How Cocaine Hijacks Your Brain Long After You Quit: Professor Jonathan Roiser on Reward, Depression and ADHD
In this episode of Rich, Powerful & Not Enough, host Jan Gerber, founder and CEO of Paracelsus Recovery in Zurich, talks with Professor Jonathan Roiser, a neuroscientist at University College London (UCL), about how cocaine acts on the brain’s dopamine-based reward system. Roiser explains that the motivation to seek rewards (wanting) can be lost in depression while the in-the-moment enjoyment of them (liking) largely remains, and that the reward system recovers after cocaine only after prolonged abstinence. The conversation is built around the case study of a wealthy, high-achieving man called James.
Listen on
Key takeaways
- Professor Jonathan Roiser explains that cocaine acts directly on the dopamine system as an artificial agent, so the brain receives a signal that something is worth pursuing even when nothing in the environment has changed.
- Roiser describes the day after cocaine as an inevitable crash: the brain needs time to make new dopamine, and ordinary rewards such as food, laughter or sex feel less potent than they did before.
- According to Roiser, the brain's chemical systems adapt as drug use continues, so a person needs proportionally more cocaine for the same effect, and the drug can become the only thing that feels worth working for.
- Roiser says that across the studies on depression with anhedonia, people's in-the-moment enjoyment is not generally dampened; the change sits mainly on the motivational side, the wanting.
- Roiser notes that once basic needs are met and life is broadly comfortable, having more money does not seem to make people particularly happier, because mood follows small, unexpected changes (prediction errors) more than total wealth.
- Roiser states that over 90% of people get better from depression with some kind of intervention, and that medication, psychological therapy, some forms of non-invasive brain stimulation and aerobic exercise all have supporting evidence.
- Roiser adds that, for someone caring for a person in a depressed state, change will not happen overnight, because the brain has to relearn and relearning takes time, beginning with very small increments.
In this episode
- 00:00 Intro
- 06:41 Why we chase things we don't even enjoy
- 14:50 Why getting richer doesn't make you happier
- 23:20 What cocaine actually does to your dopamine
- 30:25 Why ADHD can increase addiction vulnerability
- 33:30 The surprising truth about depression and pleasure
- 39:30 How do you actually recover from depression?
- 46:15 Life after addiction: Finding joy again
What does cocaine do to the brain's reward system?
Cocaine acts directly on the dopamine system as an artificial agent, signalling that something is worth pursuing, which produces motivation and excitement the environment has not earned and is followed by a crash.
Roiser starts from what the reward system is for: picking up on things in the environment that are good, things that are bad, and things worth putting effort into. Dopamine is part of that machinery. Cocaine mimics the chemical structure of the dopamine the brain makes itself, and it keeps stimulating the dopamine receptors where the natural chemical would normally act. Timing matters here, Roiser says, because the teaching signal that updates our expectations should arrive only when an outcome arrives. With cocaine in the system, the motivation and the feeling of interest are present all the time during the high.
The next day the picture reverses. Released dopamine is partly recycled and partly broken down, and the neurons need to synthesise new supplies, which takes longer than a night. Roiser calls the result an inevitable crash.
"What cocaine is doing is acting directly on this dopamine system as an artificial agent." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 23:25

Why do people keep taking cocaine when they no longer enjoy it?
According to Roiser, after the crash nothing feels as motivating as the drug, and the brain adapts so that more is needed for the same effect, until cocaine becomes the only thing that seems worth working for.
The episode draws on James's description that he did not even feel he enjoyed the cocaine. Roiser links this to the distinction between wanting and liking: the drug can keep the wanting alive without delivering much liking. He then describes homeostasis, the property of the brain's neurochemical systems to adapt as they go on, which means the more cocaine is thrown at the system, the harder it becomes to feel any effect in future. The result, in his words, is a vicious cycle in which only cocaine is worth the effort, even if the aim is just to feel halfway normal again.
Roiser also addresses why someone with low mood might reach for it. He points to temporary relief, and to a gender difference: self-medication with drugs or alcohol is common in men who do not recognise their symptoms as depression and are less likely to ask for help. He adds that most people who take cocaine recreationally do not begin with depression.
"It really does become a vicious cycle and then soon, not immediately but soon, the cocaine becomes really the only thing that's worth working for." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 27:09
Does more money make you happier?
Roiser says that once basic needs are met and life is broadly comfortable, having more money does not seem to make people particularly happier, because mood tracks small unexpected gains and losses more than total wealth.
The explanation runs through the prediction error, the gap between what you expected and what you got. Roiser gives everyday examples: a salary that arrives on schedule is not very exciting because it is fully expected, a missed one would be very disappointing, and a lottery win is an unexpected reward that activates dopamine neurons. He describes laboratory studies in which momentary changes in mood follow tiny fluctuations, a pound up or two pounds down, rather than the total accumulated, and says you can see the same in a casino.
For very wealthy people the anchor point shifts, he says, much as a house purchase makes 50 pence irrelevant, but there is still an amount that matters to them. He adds that very wealthy people still get hungry, still need social approval, and still need love from their family. The host raises the case of serial entrepreneurs whose second sale excites them less than their first.
"Having more money does not seem to make people particularly more happy." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 15:40


Why does ADHD raise the risk of addiction?
Roiser suggests that fundamental differences in the biology of people with ADHD, which also show in how amphetamine-based ADHD treatment works, probably make them more vulnerable to dependence when they use drugs at very high levels.
This topic gets a short exchange in the episode, so it is worth stating what was and was not said. The host raises the notion that people with ADHD are at higher risk of developing a dependence. Roiser agrees and gives one illustration: one of the drugs used to treat ADHD is amphetamine, for example Adderall, at a relatively low dose, not enough to produce the high people seek when they use it recreationally.
He says this probably taps into differences in the biology of people with ADHD, and that the same people are more vulnerable to dependence at very high levels of use. He does not describe the specific mechanism in the episode, and no study is cited on this point. The conversation then moves on to the drugs used to treat depression, which mostly act on the serotonin system, and to ketamine.
"That probably does tap into differences, fundamental differences in the biology of people who have ADHD." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 30:45
Is depression a loss of pleasure or a loss of motivation?
Roiser says that in the research on depression with anhedonia, people's ability to enjoy things in the moment is not generally dampened; what falls away is the motivation to seek rewards, the wanting.
Roiser introduces the wanting and liking distinction, which he says is nearly 30 years old and came from animal studies in which a reward could be devalued, for example by pairing food with poison, so that an animal would work for it but not consume it. Anhedonia is defined as a loss of interest or pleasure in previously rewarding activities, and Roiser says it maps onto this split. He applies it to James, who probably still enjoys closing a deal or laughing with his children, while the goal no longer holds value for him.
Later he describes studies in which phone prompts ask people what they are doing and how much they enjoy it. In some of those studies, depressed people rate the in-the-moment enjoyment higher, which he thinks may reflect low expectations that the real event then beats. A bad outcome, by contrast, is learned from quickly, and rewards are learned incrementally.
Near the end of the episode, the host connects this to his own experience. Gerber says he has been through quite severe depression and spent a few weeks in inpatient treatment, and that he remembers a very clear sense that doing anything made no sense. Even getting out of bed to open a window felt overwhelming. Roiser answers that when effort feels so magnified, this is not something people can easily reason their way out of.
"I have my own experience of quite severe depression. I was also in inpatient treatment for a few weeks." Jan Gerber, 44:12
"The theme seems to be much more on the motivational side. So it's the wanting as opposed to the liking." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 09:00
How does the reward system recover after cocaine?
Roiser says the dopamine and reward systems recover towards their natural function only after a period of prolonged abstinence, and that some changes can still be detected in people many years after they stopped using.
Roiser explains that cocaine changes the system so fundamentally that recovery takes time, and the host asks whether it can recover to its earlier level. Roiser answers with some caution: there is evidence from people who were dependent on cocaine that, even many years after abstinence, changes in the brain's reward and dopamine systems can still be detected, which he calls sensitisation. He does not give a timescale for full recovery in the episode.
He also states a clinical priority for anyone presenting with depression and a dependence on drugs or alcohol at the same time: deal with the dependence first, because it counteracts any other therapy and makes it very difficult to get someone better from the depression until it is addressed. On the relearning that follows, he says for family and carers that it is a gradual process, because the brain has to do the relearning.
"Only after a period of quite prolonged abstinence is the dopamine system and the brain's reward system actually going to be able to recover back towards its natural function." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 27:28
What is the story of James, and what does it illustrate?
James is the case study around which the episode is built: a man from a wealthy family business who is outwardly successful, feels like a fraud, drifts into cocaine and drinking at work, and then loses motivation after a damaging crisis.
The story is told in first-person narration across the episode. James describes a father who showed love through material things, boarding school, a musical start that he gave up for the family business, and an internal dialogue that was relentless and cruel. Cocaine returns through colleagues and becomes a way of getting through the day. After a botched deal and a crisis at home, he describes motivation vanishing, joy feeling inaccessible, and not having the energy to pick up a guitar. In the final narration he says he sought help at Paracelsus Recovery, that detox gave him rest and therapy gave him language, and that he has started playing music again.
Roiser reads the story through the reward system. He notes that James has lost the value of the goal even though he may still like the good moments that come with it.
"He's lost the value of the goal of succeeding professionally in his family company, even though he still might actually like it when good things happen, when the deal is closed." Professor Jonathan Roiser, 22:19
Terms used in this episode
- Wanting and liking. Roiser's framing of two separate parts of reward. Wanting is the motivation to seek something, which he ties strongly to dopamine. Liking is the in-the-moment enjoyment of it.
- Anhedonia. A symptom of depression defined in the episode as a loss of interest or pleasure in previously rewarding activities.
- Dopamine. A chemical produced in the brain that Roiser links to motivation and to the teaching signal behind learning about rewards.
- Prediction error. The difference between the reward expected and the reward received. In Roiser's examples, unexpected rewards activate dopamine neurons and drive learning.
- Hedonic experience. The in-the-moment experience of joy, as measured when people are asked in real time how much they enjoy what they are doing.
- Homeostasis. The tendency of the brain's neurochemical systems to adapt as they go on, so that more cocaine is needed over time for the same effect.
- Sensitisation. Roiser's word for the changes in the reward and dopamine systems that can still be detected many years after abstinence.
- Mechanistic heterogeneity. The idea that two people with the same diagnosis can have very different things happening in the brain.
- Non-invasive brain stimulation. An umbrella term Roiser uses for techniques that manipulate the brain's electrical signals without a probe in the brain, including repetitive magnetic stimulation (rTMS).
About the guest
Professor Jonathan Roiser is Professor of Neuroscience and Mental Health and Deputy Director of the UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, where he co-leads the Neuroscience and Mental Health group. He studies how the brain's reward and punishment systems relate to depression, anxiety and other mental health conditions, and joined UCL as a postdoctoral researcher in 2005. In the episode he describes his particular interest in physical activity, especially aerobic exercise. His official UCL profile gives his full publication list.
About the host
Jan Gerber is the founder and CEO of Paracelsus Recovery, a private residential clinic on Lake Zurich, and the host of Rich, Powerful & Not Enough. He speaks and writes about the wealth-health paradox and the mental health of executives and founders.
Frequently asked questions
Can people with depression still enjoy things?
According to Roiser, often yes. When people are asked in the moment how much they enjoy an activity, some studies find depressed people rate the enjoyment higher, probably because they expected so little. The loss lies mainly in seeking and anticipating rewards, which is why even picking up a guitar can seem pointless.
Why do people learn from bad outcomes faster than from good ones?
Roiser says punishments are learned very quickly while rewards tend to be learned incrementally. After a failed deal, the brain registers a strong negative prediction error and learns that acting does not pay off. He suggests this can generalise to other areas of life, so that James cannot imagine enjoying music.
How do video games and casinos use the reward system?
Roiser says game designers understand the schedule of the reward: players work for it, face some uncertainty, and receive rewards at moments that boost the prediction error, which teaches them to keep playing. The host calls this hijacking the reward system, and Roiser agrees. He says people in casinos care about momentary changes rather than their total.
Does childhood shape how the reward system works?
Roiser says the brain calibrates reward and punishment learning to the environment. In a stable home, learning should be slow. If a child meets sudden, unexplained anger, the brain should adapt to that volatility and learn very quickly. He adds that these biases may reappear when a person is under stress and acting more automatically.
What treatments for depression does Roiser mention?
He names antidepressant medication, psychological therapy, non-invasive brain stimulation (rTMS), ketamine, and aerobic exercise. He says he is convinced by the ketamine trial data and notes that a recent Cochrane review suggested aerobic exercise looks as effective as psychological therapy. The review he refers to is almost certainly the January 2026 Cochrane update, which found exercise probably makes little or no difference compared with psychological therapy (moderate-certainty evidence). He adds that it is hard to predict which will work for a given person.
Research and references mentioned
Roiser did not name the studies below. Each entry gives what he described, followed by the published work usually cited for it.
- Wanting versus liking. Roiser describes the distinction as nearly 30 years old, introduced through animal studies in which rewards were devalued, for example by pairing food with poison. The work usually cited for this is: Berridge, K. C. and Robinson, T. E. (1998). What is the role of dopamine in reward: hedonic impact, reward learning, or incentive salience? Brain Research Reviews, 28(3), 309-369. DOI | PubMed
- Prediction errors and momentary mood. Roiser describes laboratory studies in which mood follows small gains and losses rather than total winnings. The work usually cited for this is: Rutledge, R. B., Skandali, N., Dayan, P. and Dolan, R. J. (2014). A computational and neural model of momentary subjective well-being. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(33), 12252-12257. DOI
- In-the-moment enjoyment in depression. Roiser describes studies using phone prompts to ask people what they are doing and how much they enjoy it. One study of this kind, and a likely match, is: Bylsma, L. M., Taylor-Clift, A. and Rottenberg, J. (2011). Emotional reactivity to daily events in major and minor depression. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 120(1), 155-167. DOI The match is uncertain, because several experience-sampling studies exist.
- Repetitive magnetic stimulation (rTMS). Roiser says it is licensed in the UK and available on the NHS. The relevant guidance is: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2015). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for depression. Interventional procedures guidance IPG542. NICE
- Ketamine. Roiser describes about two weeks of recovery from a single dose and top-up dosing, and says he is convinced by the trial data. An early and widely cited trial is: Zarate, C. A. Jr. and colleagues (2006). A randomized trial of an N-methyl-D-aspartate antagonist in treatment-resistant major depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 63(8), 856-864. DOI The match is uncertain, because Roiser named no trial and the two-week figure may come from later work.
- Exercise compared with psychological therapy. Roiser refers to a recent Cochrane review. This is most likely: Clegg, A. J. and colleagues (2026). Exercise for depression. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, CD004366.pub7. DOI The review pooled 73 randomised trials. Compared with psychological therapy, exercise probably made little or no difference (moderate-certainty evidence from ten trials), which supports what Roiser said.
- Lasting changes in the dopamine system after cocaine. Roiser says changes can still be detected in people dependent on cocaine many years after abstinence. A classic study of dopamine responsiveness after detoxification is: Volkow, N. D. and colleagues (1997). Decreased striatal dopaminergic responsiveness in detoxified cocaine-dependent subjects. Nature, 386, 830-833. DOI The match is uncertain, because that study followed people for weeks after detoxification rather than years.
Transcript
Full transcript of the episode, lightly edited for readability.
Read the full transcriptHide the transcript
Jonathan Roiser [00:00]: Nothing will ever be as motivating or stimulating as cocaine itself. So, at least for a short period, I'm not going to feel this dreadful anymore. Well, if you don't really realise there's anything to fix, then you just naturally fall into, well, I've tried this thing. It's made me feel better. I'll just carry on doing that.
Jan Gerber [00:16]: He seems stuck in a situation where he doesn't feel like himself.
Jonathan Roiser [00:21]: Very wealthy people still get hungry. They still need social approval. They still need love from their family. It just gets out of control and they spiral. Fundamental differences in the biology of
Jan Gerber [00:30]: There's also this notion that people with ADHD are at higher risk for developing a dependence.
Jonathan Roiser [00:36]: In the moment joy, or what we call hedonic experience, depressed people in some studies actually rate the enjoyment itself as higher. And that's very, very curious, because you would think, well, how can that be? The vast majority, over 90% of people, get better from depression with some kind of intervention. Some of the side effects of antidepressants are the same as the depressive symptoms themselves. It just changes the system so fundamentally,
Jan Gerber [00:59]: But it can recover back to that level.
Jan Gerber [01:03]: Is success really worth the cost? Welcome to Rich, Powerful, and Not Enough.
James (narration) [01:19]: I grew up in a house where, if we had a Netflix series, it would have to be called Ambition Equals Love. My father was a man who turned my grandfather's village shop into a national brand. He was admired everywhere except maybe at home. I adored him as a child. I remember feeling lucky that he was my father and not one of his brothers. The thing is, he wasn't cruel. He just had the emotional availability of someone permanently late for a meeting. He never said he loved me. Love came in the form of material things.
If I mentioned art or anything he deemed useless, he would be completely silent. I learned very quickly what kinds of desire were acceptable and which were not. Boarding school did the rest. I knew my parents loved me in theory, but home felt like a place I visited rather than belonged. I grew up lonely, desperate for approval. When I left school, I decided I would be a musician. I loved that it gave me the freedom to express myself, individual from him. I was playing live music with my friends, moving from venue to venue, surrounded by people and momentum. I felt alive in a way which I hadn't before. Like I was finally inside my own life rather than watching it.
But as 30 approached, that age-old fear of wasted potential, coupled with my father's silence, began to run the show for me. I became terrified that I would waste my life with music. So I gave in to my unavoidable destiny of joining the family business. I entered high up and immediately felt like a fraud. The irony, of course, is that I was actually quite good at the job. I could close deals worth millions and still tell myself it was only because I was a loser trying to impress his father.
By 35, I'd done everything. I was married to a woman my parents approved of, and I had two beautiful children. I was closer with my father than I had ever been, and I was on a fast track to becoming CEO of the original arm of the company. I worked punishing hours and hated myself for the privilege of it. My internal dialogue was relentless and cruel. Living like this, you slowly find yourself disappearing. I became flat and hollowed out, with a constant gnawing in the pit of my stomach. In hindsight, I was completely depressed, but I thought this was what being responsible felt like.
Jan Gerber [03:33]: In this episode, I'm joined by Jonathan Roiser. He's Professor of Neuroscience and Mental Health and Deputy Director at the UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience. We discuss if pressure and responsibility can quietly recalibrate the brain's reward system. We also look at why substances like cocaine can feel functional in high-powered environments but alter your experience of joy.
Jonathan, to understand how you ended up as a neuroscientist, because when I think of it, it's probably not a career choice you make when you first consider what your job is going to be.
Jonathan Roiser [04:07]: So I decided I wanted to study biochemistry at university. That was about age 16. And unfortunately, when I got there, there were certain aspects of the course that I didn't do very well at, and I was quite lucky, because at my particular course you had the option of taking different modules in actually very different areas, and one of them was psychology. This was in the late '90s. I knew nothing about psychology, let alone mental health, which wasn't discussed at all, and it was just very obvious that I was going to study psychology. At the end of my PhD, I think it was pretty clear that I didn't really have anything else I was really considering.
Jan Gerber [04:43]: So, James, what we just learned, he doesn't feel like himself, like he has to play a role, or he's playing a role. And that's something that you often hear in the realm of people being depressed or becoming depressed: authenticity versus having to play a certain role. Can you try to unpack that neurobiologically, and also, since we started talking about punishment and reward, that seems to play a bit of a role there.
Jonathan Roiser [05:12]: Maybe I could introduce an important concept which underlies all my thinking, and I think that trying to understand mental health without understanding the brain is never going to lead us to a successful outcome in terms of developing interventions. It's very clear that what is going on in the brain of two people who have the same diagnosis might actually be very different under the hood, and that's this concept of mechanistic heterogeneity.
Jan Gerber [05:40]: Sounds very pragmatic, right? In the end, what I interpret from what you're saying is we need to completely rethink established paradigms, just look at how things really are. What are actually common denominators?
Jonathan Roiser [05:52]: Once upon a time, in the 17th, 18th century, we had a diagnosis called bilious fever. It was how you described someone who had some really nasty virus, like, you know, dengue or malaria or something of that nature. And what did it describe? Well, people are really very unwell. They've got a high temperature. They look a bit yellow, and we try to treat them as if they're all the same. But of course we don't have bilious fever anymore, because we moved from the descriptive level of diagnosis to the mechanistic level of diagnosis, and we understood germ theory in the 1870s, pathogens, and it makes different
Jan Gerber [06:24]: Yeah, I think that's very important and very interesting, those parallels, and, you know, from different fields of medicine. So why don't we try to apply this approach to this case study of James by trying to unpack a bit what's very descriptive, so at, you know, at this kind of meta level or symptoms level, what might be happening neurobiologically?
Jonathan Roiser [06:51]: So the first thing that I want to introduce is a concept which is actually rather old now, nearly 30 years old, which is the distinction between, in motivation, what we call wanting and liking. And I think this is a very important distinction. This was originally introduced to the neuroscientific literature through animal studies. And the idea is that you can have an animal, in this case I think they were mice, and you could get it to work in order to obtain a reward that it had been conditioned to work for over time. But you could devalue that reward in some way by, say, pairing it with some kind of poison.
So let's say it was food and you can make it poisonous. So you can have a situation where an animal will work, and actually also humans will work, for rewards, but when they actually receive them they won't consume them. So that's sort of the first distinction. It sounds a bit paradoxical, but that's how the neurobiology works. And you can also have things that you know you like but you're not prepared to actually work for. So we have this sort of dissociation here. So that's a very old idea, several decades old.
And I think one of the things that has become apparent in depression is this idea that we have this symptom in particular called anhedonia, which is related to motivation, which is defined as a loss of interest or pleasure in previously rewarding activities. And that sort of neatly maps onto this distinction between liking and wanting. And it transpires that when you look at all of the data that we have, all of the studies that have been conducted in this area, people who are experiencing depression, and if they're experiencing anhedonia, by and large, their ability to actually enjoy things, and we're typically talking about studies that have used primary rewards here.
Primary rewards are things that are necessary for your survival, things like food and water and sex. So the actual in-the-moment experience of pleasure doesn't seem to be particularly dampened when you look on aggregate. It might be in a few rarish cases, but that's not the general theme really. The theme seems to be much more on the motivational side. So it's the wanting as opposed to the liking. Now, I can imagine that in this case study, James probably has some aspects of his life and his work life that he does actually enjoy. So he talks about closing the deal. So that is probably still something which gives him satisfaction, the attainment of that goal.
Things like also socialising or spending time with his family, you know, laughing with his kids. These are probably all things that he is actually enjoying. But that motivational aspect, the wanting, that seems to be, in the description, where things have gone awry. This is not something that he actually values in an abstract sense anymore, in terms of his self-worth and in terms of his long-term goals and what's going to satisfy him as a person, even though he probably still enjoys doing those things, like closing the deal, for example. You've probably heard of this concept of endorphins, so basically things that kind of make you feel happy or joyful or blissed out.
Jan Gerber [10:08]: What people call the happy chemicals.
Jonathan Roiser [10:10]: Yeah, exactly. But then actually the motivational component, the wanting, is really very strongly tied to dopamine. So the way in which it's being described, which is a very common experience for people, is that this motivational aspect, and probably something related to the dopamine pathways and their ability to drive the brain's reward system, which is very well described in neuroscientific terms, has basically become blunted, and that's a characteristic feature in depression. People lose interest in all sorts of different things, not just confined to one particular domain.
Jan Gerber [10:44]: So would you, if you had to speculate, is this blunting process, is that a mechanism, something happened that went wrong in the brain?
Jonathan Roiser [10:58]: You know, even something as simple as watching a film, even though we know it's not real, right, it can dramatically change our brain. So I think these things are best understood in terms of cycles. So think about a kind of feedback loop, if you like. So James has always felt dissatisfied with this role that he's trying to play here, and over time that is probably going to influence the way in which he appraises the feedback. So he might experience the joy in the feedback, but then maybe reflecting back on it sort of loses some of its motivational value. So his expectation of how much he's going to enjoy the reward is changing, but that's not just changing overnight. So that is an iterative process.
It sounds like it occurred in this case over many years. There are biological systems which are very important in influencing how the brain's reward system functions as well, and there are good evolutionary reasons for that. So one example is actually inflammation. So the activation of the immune system, and especially when that's done in a chronic way, this is actually what happens during chronic stress. So, you know, the environment can actually directly affect your immune system as well, just through something as simple as stress. And so when you're sick, actually what you should be doing, if you're any mammal, is basically social withdrawal, reducing your level of motivation, reducing your activity, so that you can conserve energy until you're better.
Jan Gerber [12:30]: Another thing I picked up on there that I'd like to follow up on is you distinguish very clearly between these wanting and liking mechanisms, and that they're not always aligned. Actually, there can be dissonance, right? And I reckon that can be very confusing for the individual on an experiential level. So I want this but I don't like it, or I thought I would like it, but that's why I wanted it, but then it doesn't give me that kind of feeling that I projected into it.
Jonathan Roiser [12:59]: Yes, absolutely. And this is a fundamental feature of reward and punishment processing, which is the idea of the expectation versus the outcome. And this plays a key role in what I would describe as computational neuroscientific approaches. And this distance, as you describe it, is encapsulated in the concept of the prediction error. So you make an expectation about how good you think something is going to be. You think, I'm going to go to this new restaurant, it's got a Michelin star, it's going to be amazing. And then you get there and the food is incredibly disappointing.
And what you have to do is then update your expectation, which we call a value in the computational world, of how good I think that's going to be in the future. And if you go to the restaurant several times, then that can be an iterative process over time. Maybe the next time it's slightly better than you expected because you've downweighted your expectations. And there is very strong evidence in both animals and in humans that dopamine also plays a role in actually encapsulating that teaching signal.
So I would describe this as, you know, how we interact with money. So for example, if I get paid at the end of the month, it's unfortunately not that exciting for me, because it's a fully expected reward. But if I don't get paid, then for sure I'm going to be really very disappointed.
Jan Gerber [14:16]: Unexpected.
Jonathan Roiser [14:16]: Yes. Exactly. But if I win the lottery, you know, that is going to activate my dopamine neurons, because that's an unexpected reward. And so that then feeds in as a teaching signal, which is very important in these kinds of processes over time.
Jan Gerber [14:29]: That just made me think of something, a saying that I heard a couple of times: it doesn't matter if you win the lottery or break your back, in a few years you'll be the same happy, with, you know, kind of down-up regulation and then back to baseline. Can you quickly elaborate on that? Do you think that's true?
Jonathan Roiser [14:48]: Well, it's a very interesting phenomenon. There is this phenomenon that people very quickly psychologically adapt to their changing circumstances. So for people who win the lottery, I think there are normally two options. One is they manage to maintain that wealth over time, but it doesn't necessarily make them more happy. So we actually have really nice studies done in the laboratory where we can show that this concept of the prediction error is actually what drives people's momentary changes in mood.
So it's not the overall wealth that you might have accumulated over an experiment, but these tiny little fluctuations, you know, a pound up here, two pounds down there, and so on. Or just watch anyone in a casino and you'll see the same thing. They actually don't care about how much money they have right now, even if they're winning. What they really care about are these momentary changes, and that's what's really influencing their mood. Having more money does not seem to make people particularly more happy.
At a basic level it does, once people have been able to fulfil their basic needs, of course, and more money helps with that. But once you have all of those basic needs fulfilled and you're leading a broadly comfortable life, moving to a very comfortable life doesn't actually necessarily change the fact that people are probably still about the same happiness level.
Jan Gerber [16:02]: So someone like James, someone from a wealthy family or with a wealthy background, would they relate differently to reward and punishment than, let's say, somebody who doesn't have that significant wealth at their disposal?
Jonathan Roiser [16:16]: So in relation to money, I think they do. But it's just that there's a sort of recalibration. The way that I sometimes teach it to undergraduates is, if you're haggling in a market for a bunch of tomatoes or something, 50p here or there actually might be quite important, and you might walk away if the price is £1.50 as opposed to £1, but if you're buying a house, you wouldn't give it a second thought. So it's all to do with the sort of baseline to which you're comparing it. Now, with very wealthy individuals, that baseline, that anchor point, is obviously going to be radically shifted, but there is still going to be an amount of money which is going to make a difference for them. It's just going to be on a slightly different scale.
Jan Gerber [16:59]: Significantly high. That's a phenomenon you hear from serial entrepreneurs. You know, sell their first company for, let's say, a million or two million, which feels like that lottery win in a way, and then years later they sell another company for maybe even double that, but it doesn't quite tickle the brain that much.
Jonathan Roiser [17:16]: I would also put in that category social approval, you know, the ability to have loving feelings and laughter. These are all also types of reward which people work for. Really, people are operating very similarly. You know, very wealthy people still get hungry. They still need social approval. They still need love from their family.
Jan Gerber [17:35]: I would say yes. But let's say somebody who's very wealthy, who has, let's say, access to all the, you know, always goes to Michelin restaurants, so that their base level of what they deem enjoyable, or what they expect of a meal, might go up. You mentioned blunting before. That's happening not just in the realm of absolute money but also sex, food and all the other elements that you mentioned.
Jonathan Roiser [18:05]: Yes, I suppose to a certain extent it could be the case. Although, you know, the basic drives I think are still going to be very similar. I think that many of the things that we work for, you know, whether we're wealthy or not, are really in the realm of those kinds of social rewards. So, you know, the feeling that you are accepted by other people, which often goes along with laughter, actually. That's why we laugh so much in other countries where we can't speak the language, because laughter is a social signal to tell us that everything is okay. We are not going to be able to buy those things, right? Or not in an authentic way. So I think there are some things which everybody tries to work for.
Jan Gerber [18:44]: With the laughter, that makes perfect sense to me. What I observe with relationships, because obviously it creates relationship dynamics when somebody is significantly wealthy or if there's a significant gap, but then, you know, there are issues of trust and is it a genuine relationship. So you mentioned a very important word there, as long as it feels authentic, right? And I think often significant wealth can again blunt that sensation, is it really authentic, or can make people second-guess. So it's not just the monetary rewards that might be dampened but also other very important ones, which leads me actually to a following question.
There is, particularly people who are wealthy either because they're self-made and then, you know, sell their company, or people born into wealthy families who don't have to work, how does that possibly impact the, you know, punishment and rewards? Because a lot of the reward and anticipated reward is from achieving something. So if you don't have to actually go to work to achieve something
Jonathan Roiser [19:50]: Well, I think people can achieve in other domains apart from the professional domain. So, in the case study that we're talking about, our subject is very interested in music. He would love to be able to be booked, right, to play a gig in a big concert hall, for example, or maybe even just in a bar or the pub, because that is sort of a type of approval, I suppose, in a different domain. And other people will want to work in order to achieve things which are in their kind of recreational domain.
So, for example, they might put a huge amount of effort into planning a family holiday or into making their house be designed in a particular way, and then they'll spend many hours where they want to put their personal touch on the particular decoration or the design of the garden or something like this. So people also have goals in other domains apart from work. I certainly think it's possible for people to not work and still experience these, you know, wanting to achieve certain goals, because by nature we are goal-driven animals. Just like all animals in the world, we are going out and trying to obtain things, but now at a much more sophisticated or abstract level.
Jan Gerber [21:09]: Right. I think you point out something very important there, because I think a lot of people's notion of the perfect life is they can play video games all day or, you know, watch Netflix all day and do whatever they like. But that wouldn't contain any goals or any striving towards anything.
Jonathan Roiser [21:24]: Well, I think you're probably right about Netflix. Video games is actually an interesting one. And one of the things that video game designers are very, very good at, and anyone who's ever played a game, like Candy Crush Saga, or I remember when I used to be interested in games there was this game called Civilization, which you could play and sort of build up your empire over time, they are very, very good at understanding the schedule of the reward. So making people work, because if you work for a reward it tends to be more impactful when you actually achieve it. Having a little bit of uncertainty about whether it's going to work or not, and then actually delivering these rewards at the right time in order to boost the prediction error, which then teaches you that you should start playing this game longer.
Jan Gerber [22:08]: But you could say that's exactly, that's designed to hijack your reward system.
Jonathan Roiser [22:11]: That's exactly right. Yeah.
Jan Gerber [22:13]: James, seemingly stuck and not having anything or a goal that he deems worth pursuing.
Jonathan Roiser [22:19]: Yeah, he's lost the value of the goal of succeeding professionally in his family company, even though he still might actually like it when good things happen, when the deal is closed. But almost certainly, when he reflects back on those experiences, that's also going to be attenuated, because his value, his internal value, his subjective value, as we call it, has been dramatically diminished over time.
James (narration) [22:45]: I'd spent so long believing I was unworthy that success felt fraudulent. Like any day now it would be taken away from me and I'd realise it was all just one big joke I wasn't in on. I began joining my colleagues in drinking more and more after work. And through them, cocaine re-entered my life. It was encouraged, casually passed around as part of the unspoken culture, something we all shared and didn't discuss. It kept the nights going and before long became a way of getting through the day. There was a sense of secrecy to it, a feeling of belonging.
Jan Gerber [23:17]: I think for us to set the stage for this, it'd be interesting to know, or if you could explain to me as a layperson, how does cocaine work, actually, in the brain?
Jonathan Roiser [23:25]: What cocaine is doing is acting directly on this dopamine system as an artificial agent. So our brain's reward system, which the dopamine system is part of, is very well tuned to be able to pick up on things that are good in the environment, things that are bad in the environment, things that we should take action and put in effort in order to achieve. That's a basic summary of what the dopamine is going to be involved in. So if you take an artificial agent, it's like you're now poking this system and saying, "Here's something good. Here's something worth being excited about. Here's something which should have value and is going to motivate you and spur you on to action." And the way it operates is by mimicking the chemical structure of the endogenous chemical, the chemical that's produced in the brain, dopamine itself.
So the other thing about dopamine is the timing is very important. So remember we talked about the concept of the prediction error. You should only experience the prediction error when you're experiencing the outcome, you know, when you get the social approval, or conversely when you don't get the laughter after you've told the joke, or you experience the low-quality meal in the Michelin-star restaurant. But now the brain is basically stimulating these dopamine receptors all the time. And that's because the cocaine is latching on where normally the endogenous dopamine would. And then the other thing it does is basically flood the brain with cocaine. Now they are interacting with all of the other brain systems at the same time, and so the timing is critical, but now the brain is essentially going to be learning about rewards in a very different way.
So the motivation is there all the time, as James describes, and the feeling of interest and the feeling of excitement is there all the time while people are experiencing the high of the cocaine. But afterwards, so the next day, unfortunately the brain is a biological system, and biological systems work reasonably slowly. So when you release all of the dopamine in your neurons, either it gets recycled, some of it, or it just gets broken down, it gets metabolised and taken away. And actually what the brain needs to do is now to recover. So what it needs to do is actually manufacture, to synthesise new dopamine to put in those dopamine neurons. But the next day it's not soon enough to have replenished all of your dopamine supplies. And so in the immediate aftermath of taking cocaine and experiencing those very high motivational states, then there's the inevitable crash.
Jan Gerber [26:08]: Anything, like from good food to laughter to sex, nothing will actually
Jonathan Roiser [26:10]: None of it's going to be as potent as it was before. And most importantly, because it is a direct synthetic analogue, nothing will ever be as motivating or stimulating as cocaine itself.
Jan Gerber [26:25]: There's nothing but the direct intervention.
Jonathan Roiser [26:27]: Exactly.
Jan Gerber [26:28]: Cocaine is so addictive. Even a regular experience, you know, or even the high, but even just to feel normal again.
Jonathan Roiser [26:34]: Well, surely cocaine is the answer. So then it spirals, and then the brain's neurochemical systems have this property called homeostasis, which means they adapt as they go on. So the more cocaine you throw at the system, the harder it is going to be in the future, so there will gradually be a spiral and
Jan Gerber [26:58]: Eventually it's the answer.
Jonathan Roiser [26:59]: So now we need proportionally more cocaine in order to have the same effect. And it really does become a vicious cycle, and then soon, not immediately but soon, the cocaine becomes really the only thing that's worth working for, right? It's the only thing that you are prepared to want.
Jan Gerber [27:15]: Even if just to feel halfway normal again.
Jonathan Roiser [27:16]: Even if it's just to feel halfway normal, because very little else is going to do the trick in the long run. It's incredibly counterproductive, because it just changes the system so fundamentally that only after a period of quite prolonged abstinence is the dopamine system and the brain's reward system actually going to be able to recover back towards its natural function.
Jan Gerber [27:37]: But can it recover back to that level?
Jonathan Roiser [27:40]: So there is some evidence from humans who are dependent on cocaine as well, which is that even many years after abstinence you can still detect the changes in the brain reward system, and the dopamine system is, it's called sort of sensitisation. But it's interesting to reflect on James saying that actually he didn't feel like he enjoyed the cocaine. So here we've got the wanting and the liking differentiation. Again, it just feels like, well, this is the only thing that's going to make me feel any kind of energy. I'm not even necessarily getting the high.
And why, if you have someone who is presenting with depression simultaneously with drug or alcohol dependence, as I'm sure you know, the first thing that you need to do is deal with the drug or alcohol dependence, because that is going to counteract any other therapy. It's just so powerful that it's going to be very difficult to get people better from the depression until that is addressed.
Jan Gerber [28:34]: Mhm. And often you hear the notion that a dependence or an addiction is just a symptom of underlying issues, and often depression is that. But why is it then that somebody who suffers from depression, or we don't have to talk about it, it doesn't have to be a diagnosed, just depressive symptoms, very low for a long period of time, why are they particularly drawn to something like cocaine?
Jonathan Roiser [29:03]: Well, I think as James says in the example, it's this idea of the temporary relief. So, at least for a short period, I'm not going to feel this dreadful anymore. But in the long term, it's counterproductive. Now, I think we have to acknowledge also that there is a gender difference here, and the fact that James is a man is not inconsequential. So this idea of finding some kind of intervention, in this case it's pharmacological intervention, by yourself, is very common. And drug and alcohol use is very common, in particular with men who don't necessarily recognise that they're experiencing these symptoms, this thing that is recognised as depression among psychiatrists, and they're less likely to present for help as well.
So what do you do? Do you call the expert, or do you try to fix it yourself? Well, if you don't really realise there's anything to fix, then you just naturally fall into, well, I've tried this thing. It's made me feel better, so I'll just carry on doing that.
Jan Gerber [30:04]: Self-medication.
Jonathan Roiser [30:05]: Self-medication. Exactly. But of course, not everybody who ends up with a cocaine addiction initially has depression. Lots of people take it recreationally. And then there are probably a smallish percentage of people, maybe 20, 30%, for whom it just gets out of control and they spiral. But for other people, it's just very difficult to control that impulse.
Jan Gerber [30:24]: There's also this notion that people with ADHD are at higher risk for developing a dependence. Right?
Jonathan Roiser [30:32]: Yeah. Exactly. So one of the drugs that we use to treat ADHD is actually amphetamine. So that is Adderall, at a relatively low dose, not enough to experience the high that people would take if they were really going out and partying. And that probably does tap into differences, fundamental differences in the biology of people who have ADHD. And then they are also, of course, kind of more vulnerable to the dependence from very, very high levels of use.
Jan Gerber [31:00]: Differently.
Jonathan Roiser [31:00]: Exactly. And then the other thing that's worth saying is that of course we do use drugs in order to treat depression. Most of the drugs we use to treat depression actually work on the serotonin system.
Jan Gerber [31:12]: Where do you put interventions such as ketamine or psychedelic-assisted therapies, particularly for depression, because that seems to be exactly those often kind of one-hit phenomena?
Jonathan Roiser [31:23]: Yeah. The immediate psychoactive effect of ketamine is very different to cocaine. People do not report it in the same way, right? It's much more like actually a psychedelic experience, changes in time perception, these visual changes and things like that. And it's very, very short. But the problem is that from the one hit you will get about two weeks of recovery, and then people gradually start to slip back into the depression again. So the way in which ketamine is administered now is more on a schedule, so that people actually have to sort of come for a top-up dose over time. But it is very effective, and I'm very convinced by the trial data.
James (narration) [32:06]: The collapse was inevitable. I botched a crucial deal costing the company millions. I disappeared for days because my wife had found out about my cocaine abuse. She had threatened to leave me, and my answer was to go on a days-long bender. I drank like I had something to prove. I borrowed a guitar. I hit open mic nights. I was so drunk I forgot the chords halfway through the first song. Someone laughed. I even tried to make a pass at a woman at the bar. She didn't look angry, just uncomfortable. I drove home, furious. Furious that I'd wasted years living someone else's idea of a life. I remember rain, headlights, and then nothing.
When I awoke, she was there. The children were there. She didn't scream. She just said, "What if they had been in the car?"
Everything broke all at once. Motivation had vanished. I couldn't summon the energy to participate in my own life. I felt all colour had bled out and left me hollow. My marriage was already ending, and I was scared that if I walked away from everything all at once, I might not survive it. I was just watching it happen while fading out of my own life. I remembered music sometimes, but I couldn't summon the energy to pick up a guitar or play. Joy felt inaccessible. It was just another reminder of the life that I had stopped living.
Jan Gerber [33:28]: So someone like James who suffers from depression, what is it that is affecting their motivation to perform or to seek enjoyment?
Jonathan Roiser [33:38]: So I think the critical word here is the "seek", and I want to come back to this distinction between wanting and liking, which we discussed earlier, in depression. The vast majority of the time when we're looking at the symptom of anhedonia, it is really this motivational component which is important, and James describes that very clearly here. This idea that he's not actually doing very much. He's probably sitting around, maybe he's looking at his phone, maybe he's watching TV or looking at the internet, and he describes things happening to him as opposed to him going out and actively seeking things or making things happen.
And obviously he's experienced this dramatic negative prediction error when he's fluffed a deal which was going to be very important for his company. And so that has had this very pronounced system change in his reward system, because now he's got this big negative prediction error, which is basically saying, well, previously when you acted you were able to achieve the goal, but this time you acted and you couldn't achieve the goal. So now we're going to learn that the right thing to do is actually not to try to do that, because it's going to give us a negative prediction error next time. So it's very quick learning, the punishment
Jan Gerber [34:54]: To avoid the punishment.
Jonathan Roiser [34:54]: Exactly. And punishments are learned very quickly. Rewards tend to be learned quite incrementally. Now, I'm speculating here, that if James actually engaged in an activity that he found enjoyable, he would actually enjoy it. And that's because, when you look at the data, when you look at studies that have tried to do this, we can have an app on people's phones and we can just ping them at certain times of the day and say, "What are you doing now? And how much are you enjoying it?" And then we can look at the things that are positive things. You know, it's like, I'm enjoying a conversation with a friend, or I'm watching a good TV series, and we can see how much they enjoy it.
Very interestingly, when you ask people in the moment, and that's what we're talking about, this in-the-moment joy, or what we call hedonic experience, when you do that, depressed people in some studies actually rate the enjoyment itself as higher. And that's very, very curious, because you would think, well, how can that be? Because surely it should be dampened. Well, probably it's a consequence of their expectation of that reward as being quite low, and then the actual event being better than they expected. The prediction error is positive.
So James has had this very adverse, negative experience in the professional context. Maybe that's now bled into, because the brain is very good at generalising stuff, bled into all areas of his life. So now he can't even get the energy to pick up his guitar, because he can't imagine the enjoyment.
Jan Gerber [36:18]: He predicts it won't be enjoyable.
Jonathan Roiser [36:19]: He's not going to pick up his guitar, not going to expend the cognitive effort, maybe even the physical effort, of actually getting that right and playing for an hour in order to produce something he actually enjoys.
Jan Gerber [36:29]: Okay. What about the childhood upbringing? Can the foundations of how one experiences reward and punishment from their childhood have an impact on how that plays out later in life?
Jonathan Roiser [36:50]: So remember, the brain is adaptive. The brain is always responding to the environment. The brain is keeping us alive and trying to allow us to propagate the next generation, taking care of our kids. That's basically what it's trying to do all the time. So it will calibrate the reward and punishment system to the environment in which it's operating. If you live in a very stable environment, then actually what you should learn to do is learn about things relatively slowly, because, let's say you're a kid and most of the time you're getting loving care from your parents, but one day your parents are in a bad mood and they shout at you for no particular reason. What should you do? What should your brain do?
Actually, your brain should adapt to this volatility. So it actually should start learning very, very quickly, and you're going to have these same behavioural biases again, probably playing out when you have to operate more automatically and less deliberatively.
Jan Gerber [37:46]: So it can be unlearned, but it's harder to unlearn if it's
Jonathan Roiser [37:50]: Maybe that you return to it in times when you have to think a lot about other things or deal with a lot of stress in your life.
Jan Gerber [37:55]: Yeah. Okay. I want to come to a specific point with punishment and reward. If you could generalise, I think, evolutionarily, as you explain, we seek reward, we try to avoid punishment for evolutionary reasons. How does it fit in when people self-harm, for instance, which is a kind of punishment or experience of pain?
Jonathan Roiser [38:24]: So I'm not an expert in this area, but I think the best way of thinking about it, through the lens of reward and punishment processing, and when we say self-harm here, by the way, we're not talking about suicidal tendencies, right, we're talking about people self-injuring, and then typically that is to cope with some form of distress. So people have got these very negative thoughts, or they've had a very negative experience, which is sort of psychic pain, and they need some kind of relief from them. So in some ways the pain can have simultaneously a kind of primary punishing characteristic, but it also has this characteristic of relieving some kind of other pain at the same time, essentially through distraction.
So you've learned the distraction comes from the pain, and so over time the prediction error is going to teach you that the prediction error for the pain is not as big as the prediction error for the reward.
Jan Gerber [39:25]: In this case the relief is the reward.
Jonathan Roiser [39:27]: Yes.
Jan Gerber [39:27]: As someone who finds themselves in a position such as James, not feeling any pleasure, feeling stuck, feeling dissociated, feeling depressed, basically, what would be some hands-on tools or recommendations in that situation?
Jonathan Roiser [39:50]: So, I think for someone who ends up in the low situation that James has unfortunately ended up in, it's always important to remember that we have effective treatments, and it can be very tempting to kind of experience despair and that nothing is going to work and I'm going to feel this way forever. And the first thing to remember is that the vast majority, over 90% of people, get better from depression with some kind of intervention. There is overwhelming evidence, despite some scepticism, overwhelming evidence for the effectiveness of antidepressant medications and psychological therapy and some forms of non-invasive brain stimulation. And my particular area of interest is physical activity, so in particular aerobic exercise. But as I say, we're very bad at predicting which of these is going to be effective for the person who is standing in front of us.
Jan Gerber [40:51]: Could you just do all of them?
Jonathan Roiser [40:52]: I always say you may as well try them all. If you get side effects on some of them, or if some of them don't work, then of course you can stop.
Jan Gerber [41:01]: One is, you mentioned non-invasive brain stimulation. What is that?
Jonathan Roiser [41:03]: So non-invasive brain stimulation is an umbrella term that refers to a variety of different techniques in which we use the biology of the brain, the way in which it operates, which is through electrical signals, and try to manipulate that without having to put some kind of probe into the brain. There are a couple of dozen core circuits in the brain. One of them is very important in what you might think of as something like cognitive control. So your ability to control your thoughts, which goes along with things like being able to remember a phone number or suppress things that you don't want to have to think about. All of these kinds of things are actually very disrupted in depression.
And there's one node in this circuit which is in the front of the brain. It's about here. It's called the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. And there were several studies done, starting about the mid-2000s, which suggested that if we apply basically magnetic pulses, and what they do actually is disrupt ongoing activity, so it's a bit like injecting white noise into a system that then propagates through the rest of the circuit, people would come in five days a week, typically they would receive 20 minutes of stimulation.
Jan Gerber [42:20]: This is rTMS.
Jonathan Roiser [42:21]: And this is rTMS. rTMS is licensed in the UK. You can actually get it on the NHS. We don't know for an individual which is the appropriate brain circuit to be targeting, and sometimes treatments might even be counterproductive, right? So some classes of antidepressant, if someone has, you know, particularly strong motivational symptoms, they might not target that particular circuit particularly well and they might give a bunch of side effects. So unfortunately people might end up feeling worse, and unfortunately some of the side effects of antidepressants are the same as the depressive symptoms themselves, like difficulty sleeping, for example, sexual dysfunction. So in some cases it might exacerbate the symptoms.
But what you have to try to do, and work with a clinician of course, is to try and figure out the right kind of treatment combination. And I should also say that physical exercise, it looks like, when you look at all of the data in aggregate, there was a recent Cochrane review, which is a really high-quality piece of research which aggregates lots of data together, they suggested that one of the conclusions was that at least for aerobic exercise it seems to be as effective as psychological therapy, and that's quite a big claim, because psychological therapy is really quite effective for depression.
Jan Gerber [43:35]: Aerobic exercise meaning, for low level?
Jonathan Roiser [43:37]: It means, at least in the UK, adhering to government recommendations for the kind of physical exercise we should all be doing, like 150 minutes a week that's going to get you sweaty or out of breath, and typically that's going to be, you know, two or three times a week for most people, doing about half an hour to an hour of running, cycling, swimming, whatever it is that works for people. It doesn't just have to be in the gym. And I think that's really important, because there's a real social difficulty there with people who don't perceive the gym as being for them. So any kind of activity that gets you sweaty or out of breath.
Jan Gerber [44:10]: And when you're depressed, it's probably even harder to
Jonathan Roiser [44:12]: Very difficult to get going when you're depressed, of course, but starting slowly is always the key.
Jan Gerber [44:16]: Another thing you mentioned early on, when we talked about when someone finds themselves in this depressed or stuck situation, you mentioned the word "tempting". It's very tempting to just kind of stay there, and the default state. Default state. I can really relate to that. I have my own experience of quite severe depression. I was also in inpatient treatment for a few weeks.
Jonathan Roiser [44:43]: Yeah.
Jan Gerber [44:44]: And I do remember, in these depressive states, a very clear understanding that doing anything just makes no sense. And it was such a clarity, in a way, almost brutal, that it really, now he's explained it in this way, makes really a lot of sense to me, what happened back then. So even at some point just getting out of bed and opening the window and getting a breath of fresh air was an overwhelming thought.
Jonathan Roiser [45:14]: Yeah. And I think the important thing to realise is that when people are in this state, when the effort is so magnified, it isn't really accessible to conscious awareness in the way that people might be tempted to say, well, why don't they just remember that actually it doesn't take that much effort. So I think understanding, as a carer or a family member, things are not going to change overnight, and it's always going to be a gradual process, because the brain has to do the relearning, and the relearning takes time.
Jan Gerber [45:43]: Starts with very small increments.
Jonathan Roiser [45:45]: It starts with it. Yeah, it starts with small increments.
Jan Gerber [45:48]: Makes a lot of sense. Thank you. Thanks to Jonathan for joining us today. If you've heard anything in this episode that you recognise in yourself, a friend, or a family member, do remember it doesn't matter what your last name is, how much you've achieved, or how others see you. Pain is real, and recovery can start now. If you've enjoyed this episode, please hit the subscribe button to get notified when each episode lands. Thank you.
James (narration) [46:13]: When I finally made the decision to get help, I went to Paracelsus Recovery. Detox gave me rest and therapy gave me language. I began to understand that my anger wasn't just for my father, but for my mother, too. And her absence during those boarding school years. There was still anger there, but now I can see it belongs to the boy in me who learned to survive by pretending he didn't need anyone. My life totally changed when I left the company. I feel a lot more space now that I've done the one thing I was so terrified of, completely disappointing my father and admitting how much I didn't want to do that. I could finally make actual choices for myself. I've even started playing music again. Music now reminds me that it's possible to want something purely because it belongs to me, not because it's a rebellion. I've been able to sober up, see my children, and live a life that doesn't revolve around punishing myself for not being someone else.
More episodes
